Every score on this site decomposes into eight dimensions, and each dimension into records with evidence ids. This post walks one vendor's total from its records.
The example vendor is the median of the ranking, chosen by position so the example does not feature the leader: HCLTech, rank 7 of 13, total 21.
| Dimension | Calculation from the records | Score | Evidence ids |
|---|---|---|---|
| d1 Logistics case study depth | 3 recorded case studies with grades A 0, B 2, C 1 give 5 points; min(25, round(25 x 5 / 12)) = 10. | 10/25 | ev-0443 ev-0452 ev-0466 |
| d2 Case study evidence quality | Share of grade A case studies 0/3; round(15 x share), capped at 10 with one case study = 0. | 0/15 | |
| d3 Logistics system coverage | 2 distinct systems (EDI and carrier integrations, WMS); round(12 x 2 / 6) = 4. | 4/12 | ev-0455 ev-0469 |
| d4 Client review evidence in logistics | 0 reviews within 36 months and 0 older (half weight); min(15, round(15 x weighted / 5)) = 0. | 0/15 | |
| d5 Review specificity | 0 of 0 counted reviews are specific; score 0. | 0/8 | |
| d6 Logistics testing capability evidence | 1 testing types evidenced (test automation); round(10 x 1 / 4) = 3. | 3/10 | ev-0446 ev-0456 ev-0470 |
| d7 Delivery footprint and continuity | Founded 10+ years ago (two sources): no; size 51+ (two sources): no; 2+ regions (two sources): yes; an engagement of 12+ months: no; 2 points each = 2. | 2/8 | ev-0433 ev-0434 ev-0435 ev-0436 ev-0438 ev-0439 |
| d8 Transparency | Engagement models on the vendor site: yes; certification with a register source: no; pricing published: no; score 2. | 2/7 | ev-0441 |
Records behind this score: Accelerating DevOps maturity through automated test coverage (HCLTech, grade C); Transforming automotive logistics through GenAI adoption and value-stream re-engineering (HCLTech, grade B); Getting every food order right through smarter warehouse system testing (HCLTech, grade B).
Sum: 10 + 0 + 4 + 0 + 0 + 3 + 2 + 2 = 21. Scoring date 2026-11-11.
The same calculation runs for every vendor in scripts/compute-scores.ts; a second run reproduces the output byte for byte. Rules and weights: methodology. Full ranking: ranking.